Sgt, I applaud you for thinking outside the box. It's like the guy in body shop school who was superb at color matching. Give him a paint chip and a body panel, and he'd make it match every time. Found out later he'd mix up a batch of paint that was close, paint the panel, and then mask off and paint the chip he was given.
Back in the day (very early 80s), my company was building a prototype switching power supply for a 25" computer monitor system. We brought in this pseudo-genius circuit designer guy, who made up this closed feedback, highly resilient circuit, guaranteed to work first time.
So, believing the hype, they told him "Go build it."
So he did. The main switching transistor was a BU208. They cost about $11 each in quantity.
He and I worked on it for days. Switch it on, get it close to the voltage they wanted, and then
*pop* the BU208 would fry. Switch out the control grid (resistor array in the feedback circuit) values, put in another BU208, fire it up again.
By the time the circuit was stable, we went through about 200 of those transistors. Plus labor. Plus the designer's time and expenses. I think I even asked him why he didn't put in a variable resistor in the control grid to dial it in. I was told "That's not how a real engineer does things". Well, at that time, I was a technician: less concerned with
why something doesn't work, more concerned with
getting it working.And now I'm an engineer, but I learned what to do and what not to do from that guy.
Luke M
Used to have a 1979 CB750L, sold it as a parts bike, now riding a slightly modified 1984 VT700C. Network/Field Engineer. Central OH, USA, Earth, Sol System, Milky Way Galaxy, Universe.